FUNCTIONAL ORGANIZATION OF STREAM FISH ASSEMBLAGES IN RELATION TO HYDROLOGICAL
VARIABILITY
Ecology, 76(2), 1995, pp. 606-627
N. LeRoy Poff
Dept. of Zoology, University of Maryland, College
Park, Maryland 20742 USA
J. David Allan
School of Natural Resources & Environment, University
of Michigan, Ann Arbor, Michigan 48109 USA
Stream fish assemblage data for 34 sites in Wisconsin and Minnesota
were obtained from archived sources and were used in conjunction with long-term
hydrological data to test the hypothesis that functional organization of
fish communities is related to hydrological variability. For each of the
106 species present in the data set, six categories of species traits were
derived to describe habitat, trophic, morphological, and tolerance characteristics.
A hierarchical clustering routine was used to identify two functionally
similar groups of assemblages defined in terms of species presence/absence.
Hydrological factors describing streamflow variability and predictability,
as well as frequency and predictability of high flow and low flow extremes,
were derived for each of the 34 sites and employed to explain differences
among the functionally defined groups. Canonical discriminant analysis
revealed that the hydrological data could clearly separate the two ecologically
defined groups of assemblages, which were associated with either hydrologically
variable streams (high coefficient of variation of daily flows, moderate
frequency of spates) or hydrologically stable streams (high predictability
of daily flows, stable baseflow conditions). Discriminant functions based
on hydrological information classified the 34 fish assemblages into the
correct ecological group with 85% accuracy. Assemblages from hydrologically
variable sites had generalized feeding strategies, were associated with
silt and general substrata, were characterized by slow-velocity species
with headwater affinities, and were tolerant to silt. Proportions of species
traits present at the 34 sites were regressed against an index of hydrological
stability derived from a principal components analysis to test the hypothesis
that functional organization of assemblages varied across a gradient of
hydrological stability. Results were complementary with the discriminant
analysis. Findings were in general agreement with theoretical predictions
that variable habitats should support resource generalists while stable
habitats should be characterized by a higher proportion of specialist species.
Several species of fish were identified as indicative of the variable-stable
hydrological gradient among stream sites. A taxonomic analysis showed strong
geographic patterns in species composition of the 34 assemblages. However,
zoogeographic constraints did not explain the observed relationship between
stream hydrology and functional organization of fish assemblages. The strong
hydrological-assemblage relations found in the 34 midwestern sites suggest
that hydrological factors are significant environmental variables influencing
fish assemblage structure, and that hydrological alterations induced by
climate change (or other anthropogenic disturbances) could modify stream
fish assemblage structure in this region.
Key words: community assembly; community structure;
environmental variability; fishes; hydrological regime; midwestern U.S.;
physical habitat template; regional patterns; scale; species traits; streams.
Last updated November 22, 1999
J.D. Allan, School of Natural Resources & Environment
University of Michigan